A few things: You mentioned four valid MAC addresses, but what about the IP addresses? The Speadstream NATs down to 192.168.254.x. If your computer is reporting an IP address as 169.x.x.x, the internal DHCP server on the router went haywire. When you get into this situation, do the following: Release all computer's DHCP address (ipconfig /release on each machine). Then shut them all down. Next, unplug the router from the power source. Let it sit for at least 30 seconds so it flushes all the internal IP addresses. Turn the router back on and let it stabilize. Then flip your PCs back on. Another thing is to check to see if you have security enabled on the router. If so, double check that the registered MAC addresses match the allowed MAC addresses in the security table (and have outbound access).